Everyone Wanted House Prices to Fall. Now They Are, So Why Aren't People Buying?

For years, Australians have complained that property is too expensive. Now prices are falling, buyers have greater negotiating power, and suddenly everyone is frightened to make a move.
Isn't that interesting?
We spend years hearing that people are priced out of the market, that property prices are unsustainable and that something needs to change.
Well, something has changed.
And the statistics are becoming impossible to ignore.
According to Cotality's November 2026 Home Value Index, national dwelling values have declined for seven consecutive months, falling 6.7% since their March peak.
That's equivalent to approximately $63,400 being wiped off the value of the median Australian dwelling.
Even more interesting is the speed of the correction.
Combined capital-city property values have fallen 8.1% in just seven months, with the decline tracking faster than any previous downturn over the past 40 years.
But instead of buyers celebrating the opportunity to enter the market at lower prices, many are retreating.
So here's my question: Do Australians actually want more affordable property, or do they only feel comfortable buying when everyone else is buying?
The Numbers Tell an Interesting Story
Let's look at what's really happening.
According to Cotality, the estimated number of Australian home sales over the three months leading into November was approximately 23% lower than the same period last year.
Properties are taking longer to sell.
In September, the median selling time nationally increased to 41 days, compared with just 26 days a year earlier.
Meanwhile, total advertised property listings were 19.1% higher than a year ago.
Think about that for a moment.
More properties available for buyers to choose from.
Fewer properties actually selling.
Longer selling periods.
And increasingly, vendors having to adjust their price expectations.
Cotality's latest figures show median vendor discounting reaching 4.7%, the largest discounting level recorded since May 2019.
For buyers, that represents a meaningful shift in negotiating conditions, although discounts vary enormously between individual properties and locations.
Yet many buyers are waiting for someone else to tell them it's safe to buy.
When property prices were climbing, people were afraid of missing out.
Now that they're falling, people are afraid of buying too soon.
The psychology of property is fascinating.
Melbourne Buyers Should Be Paying Attention
The Melbourne market tells an especially interesting story.
According to Cotality, Melbourne dwelling values were 7.6% lower over the 12 months to October 2026.
Even more surprisingly, Melbourne property values were 7.3% lower than they were five years ago.
Five years!
For a city that has historically attracted enormous attention from property investors and homebuyers, that statistic deserves serious consideration.
Now let's look at auctions.
For the week ending 25 October 2026, Melbourne recorded a final auction clearance rate of just 50.2%.
During the equivalent week in 2025, it was 67.4%.
That's a substantial reduction in the proportion of properties successfully selling at or around auction.
Of course, individual suburbs and quality properties continue to perform differently.
But the broader message is clear.
Buyers in parts of Melbourne may have negotiating opportunities that were far less common when confidence and competition were stronger.
And that brings me to a question I regularly consider when advising buyers.
Why are people so comfortable competing against several other purchasers for the same property, yet become nervous when they're the only serious buyer at the negotiating table?
But There's a Catch: Cheaper Property Doesn't Necessarily Mean More Affordable Property
This is where the conversation needs to become intelligent rather than emotional.
On 3 November 2026, the Reserve Bank increased the cash rate to 4.85%, its fifth interest rate increase this year.
At the same time, Australia's annual inflation rate had reached 4.3% in September.
These are genuine financial pressures.
In fact, Cotality estimated that the first four interest rate increases of 2026 had already reduced the borrowing capacity of a median-income household by approximately $90,000, or 9%.
And that estimate was made before November's additional increase.
So, while property prices have fallen, some buyers are also able to borrow substantially less.
That's an important distinction.
A $60,000 reduction in a property's value might look attractive on paper, but if your borrowing capacity has declined by $90,000, that property may still be out of reach.
We need to stop confusing a declining property market with guaranteed affordability.
A property is only affordable when the purchase price, borrowing costs and ongoing expenses work within your individual financial circumstances.
So Why Am I Still Seeing Opportunities?
Because purchasing property isn't simply about the market going up or down.
It's about understanding the relationship between value, quality, competition and long-term objectives.
In stronger markets, buyers can find themselves under enormous pressure.
They attend an inspection on Saturday, fall in love with a property, organise a contract review and suddenly discover there are six other interested parties.
Before they know it, they're being encouraged to submit their highest offer.
Emotions enter the equation.
Budgets stretch.
Due diligence gets rushed.
And sometimes people pay substantially more than a property is reasonably worth.
A softer market can change that dynamic.
Buyers may have more time to investigate, consider alternatives and negotiate appropriate conditions.
But there's something I want to be particularly clear about.
Not every property that has fallen in price represents a good buying opportunity.
A house with serious structural concerns, a compromised position, an awkwardly configured allotment or poor long-term market appeal doesn't suddenly become a smart investment because it's $50,000 cheaper.
You can renovate a house.
You cannot renovate its location.
And you certainly cannot change the shape of the land.
Buying well requires far more than securing a discount.
What Happens When Confidence Returns?
One of the most interesting aspects of property markets is that confidence can change much faster than the physical supply of housing.
Australia still faces significant housing supply challenges, despite the current slowdown in buyer demand.
Cotality's October Housing Chart Pack highlighted the need for approximately 1.4 million additional homes by 2035 to accommodate projected population growth.
That's an important longer-term consideration.
However, housing shortages do not guarantee that prices will immediately recover. Borrowing capacity, employment, interest rates and local market conditions all influence what buyers can actually pay.
And that is why no responsible property professional should be promising buyers that prices have reached the bottom.
They may fall further.
Some locations may take years to recover.
Others may prove more resilient.
But what happens if buyers wait until confidence has returned, only to find themselves competing against the very purchasers who were absent during the downturn?
That is a risk worth considering.
The Most Expensive Mistake Might Be Following the Crowd
Throughout my years working in property, one thing has become increasingly apparent.
People often feel more comfortable making a decision when everyone around them is making the same decision.
But popularity doesn't establish value.
Just because five people want the same house doesn't mean it's worth the price they're prepared to pay.
And just because nobody else is making an offer doesn't mean the property isn't worth buying.
The strongest property decisions come from understanding the asset, the local market, your financial position and your long-term objectives.
Not from the number of other buyers attending an open inspection.
So, Should Everyone Be Buying Right Now?
Absolutely not.
If your finances are stretched, your employment is uncertain or you're depending on interest rates falling to make your repayments affordable, buying may not be appropriate.
But for purchasers with secure finances, adequate buffers and a clear long-term strategy, it could be worth taking a closer look at the opportunities emerging in selected markets.
Rather than asking whether property prices will fall another 5%, perhaps buyers should be asking:
Am I buying in the right location?
Is this a quality asset with strong long-term appeal?
What do the comparable sales tell me?
Am I paying a fair price?
And can I comfortably afford to hold this property if market conditions remain difficult?
Because the best time to buy isn't necessarily when property prices are rising, falling or sitting at the bottom of a cycle.
It's when you can purchase the right property, at the right price, for the right reasons.
And sometimes, the greatest opportunity isn't finding a property nobody else can afford.
It's recognising the value in a property when everyone else is too nervous to make a decision.
Perhaps it's time we stopped asking whether the market is ready for buyers.
And started asking whether buyers are ready to approach the market differently.









Comments