We Want Cheaper Homes, Fewer Investors and 1.2 Million New Homes. What Could Possibly Go Wrong?

Australia's property market is doing something rather extraordinary right now.
We want cheaper homes.
We want cheaper rents.
We want more first-home buyers.
We want 1.2 million new homes.
We want developers to build more.
We want less investor competition for established property.
And Australia's population continues to grow.
Individually, you can make a perfectly reasonable argument for almost every one of those objectives.
Put them all together, however, and I have a fairly simple question:
Does any of this actually add up?
Because Australia's housing crisis is increasingly looking less like a property problem and more like a mathematics problem.
And mathematics is notoriously difficult to legislate away.
Let's start with the number nobody can ignore
Australia's population has now reached approximately 27.92 million people.
In the latest 12-month period measured by the ABS, to March 2026, our population increased by another:
392,700 people.
Of that growth, approximately 292,100 came from net overseas migration.
Victoria alone added approximately 109,500 people in just one year, growing by 1.6%.
This isn't an argument for or against immigration.
It is simply mathematics.
Every additional person needs somewhere to live.
Maybe they buy.
Maybe they rent.
Maybe they live with family.
Maybe they share.
But ultimately:
people require housing.
Housing demand doesn't care which political party you vote for.
It doesn't care what someone says on Facebook.
And it certainly doesn't disappear because we would prefer property to be more affordable.
So while Australia's population continues growing, how are we going with the homes?
Well...
That's where things get interesting.
We promised 1.2 million new homes
Under the National Housing Accord, Australia is targeting:
1.2 million new homes over five years to June 2029.
That's an average of approximately 240,000 homes every year.
The independent National Housing Supply and Affordability Council still considers that target appropriate.
But it doesn't expect us to reach it on time.
Its April 2026 modelling estimated approximately 980,000 homes would be delivered during the five-year Accord period — around 220,000 short of the target.
And by its August 2026 update, the Council estimated Australia would not actually reach the 1.2 million target until around the:
December quarter of 2030.
That's roughly a year and a half late.
So when somebody says:
“Don't worry. We'll just build more houses.”
It's worth remembering that Australia has been trying to do exactly that.
To be fair, construction has improved
This article isn't going to cherry-pick numbers simply to make property sound scarce.
There has been some improvement.
In the June quarter of 2026, dwelling commencements increased 7.0% to 52,201 homes.
Dwelling completions increased 5.8% to 47,168.
And in September, dwelling approvals increased 5.1% in a single month to 17,948.
That's positive.
But dig slightly deeper.
Those September approvals were still 0.8% lower than a year earlier.
Private house approvals actually fell 5.3% during September, while the increase came largely from apartments, townhouses and other non-house dwellings.
And the National Housing Supply and Affordability Council says house construction costs are now around:
51% higher than before the COVID-19 pandemic.
It has also warned that higher costs, interest rates and softer housing-market sentiment may cause some construction to be deferred.
So yes, we're building.
The problem is whether we're building enough.
Fast enough.
In the right places.
At prices people can actually afford.
Those are very different questions.
Meanwhile, we're trying to change investor behaviour
From 1 July 2027, negative gearing on residential property will generally be restricted to new builds.
Properties held before the policy announcement on 12 May 2026 are grandfathered.
Investors who purchase established housing after that date can still offset residential-property losses against residential income and carry excess losses forward, but they will generally no longer be able to offset those losses against income such as wages.
The stated objective is to direct more investor capital towards new housing supply.
On paper?
There's logic to it.
If investors are going to receive tax assistance, why not encourage them to invest in property that adds another home?
Fair question.
But property policy has an annoying habit of looking extremely tidy on paper.
The real world tends to be messier.
Because investors have just slammed on the brakes
Yesterday, the Australian Bureau of Statistics released its latest lending figures.
And this is where the story becomes very interesting.
During the September quarter of 2026:
The number of new investor housing loans fell 30.6%.
The value of new investor loans fell:
32.3%.
In.
Three.
Months.
Compared with a year earlier, investor loan numbers are now down:
38.5%.
And investor lending by value is down:
38.1%.
The ABS says the September-quarter falls in both the number and value of investor loans were the:
largest quarterly falls on record.
Investor lending has now fallen for three consecutive quarters.
That's not background noise.
Something significant has changed.
“Great. Investors are finally leaving.”
I can already hear the argument.
Good.
Fewer investors competing with first-home buyers.
Lower property prices.
More opportunity for owner-occupiers.
And there is genuine merit in that position.
An investor buying an existing house doesn't create another house.
If that property instead goes to a first-home buyer, we've helped somebody into home ownership.
Fantastic.
But...
There's one fairly inconvenient statistic sitting beside the investor numbers.
First-home buyer lending fell too.
The number of new owner-occupier first-home buyer loans fell 8.6% in the September quarter.
And compared with a year earlier, first-home buyer loan numbers are down:
12.3%.
Owner-occupier borrowing overall fell 5.3% in the quarter.
So apparently simply removing investors from the equation doesn't automatically result in thousands of first-home buyers charging through the front door.
Why?
Because affordability is more complicated than who you're bidding against.
There is still:
income,
deposit size,
borrowing capacity,
interest rates,
bank servicing,
employment security,
and the actual price of the property.
Perhaps housing affordability doesn't have one villain after all.
Then the RBA joined the party
Australia's cash rate is now:
4.85%.
It was 3.60% at the end of 2025.
That's a rise of 1.25 percentage points during 2026 alone.
And higher rates don't only affect people bidding at auctions.
They affect:
homeowners,
first-home buyers,
property investors,
developers,
builders,
project finance,
construction feasibility,
and ultimately the price required to make new housing commercially viable.
Which creates yet another interesting contradiction.
We're using higher rates to reduce demand...
while those same higher rates can also make tomorrow's housing more difficult to finance and build.
Nobody said housing policy was easy.
Property prices are falling too
Here's where this becomes almost bizarre.
Australia is struggling to build enough housing.
Our population is still growing.
Construction costs remain elevated.
And yet national housing prices in September were:
4.7% below their March 2026 peak.
The Reserve Bank describes the current downturn as one of the steepest housing-price downturns of the past 50 years, with falls spreading across most capital cities.
So how can Australia simultaneously have:
A housing shortage
and
falling property prices?
Quite easily.
Because short-term property prices and long-term housing fundamentals are not the same thing.
The short-term market is driven heavily by money and emotion
Interest rates.
Borrowing capacity.
Government policy.
Consumer confidence.
Employment.
Bank lending.
Expectations.
Fear.
When borrowing capacity falls quickly enough, people simply can't pay yesterday's prices.
And when buyers believe prices will fall further?
They wait.
That's exactly what we're seeing.
But longer-term housing demand is influenced by something quite different.
Population.
Household formation.
Employment centres.
Infrastructure.
Rental demand.
Land availability.
Construction.
And ultimately:
supply versus demand.
That's why prices can fall today while a housing shortage continues underneath.
Both things can be true at the same time.
And this is where Australia gets itself tied in knots
Let's look at what we're trying to achieve.
We want cheaper established property.
But falling established property prices can make competing new developments less feasible.
We want fewer investors competing with first-home buyers.
But investors also provide much of Australia's private rental housing.
We want investors to purchase new property instead.
But new property is often considerably more expensive to develop because construction costs have exploded.
We want lower rents.
But rental supply still requires somebody to provide the capital.
We want developers to build more homes.
But developers need projects to be financially viable.
We want lower inflation.
So interest rates rise.
But higher interest rates increase financing costs for the very housing we're trying to build.
And we want the Australian economy and population to continue growing.
Which means...
we need more housing.
See the problem?
You cannot tax your way out of a housing shortage
Tax policy can absolutely change behaviour.
It can shift investors from established property towards new construction.
It can reduce investor competition.
It can influence property values.
There may be perfectly legitimate reasons for doing all of those things.
But taxation alone cannot:
pour a concrete slab,
frame a house,
install a kitchen,
train another electrician,
release another parcel of serviced land,
or make an unprofitable apartment development suddenly stack up financially.
Eventually somebody still has to:
Build. The. Houses.
And despite the recent improvement in commencements and approvals, Australia's own independent housing council still doesn't expect us to reach the 1.2 million-home target on time.
That's the part of this debate I think deserves considerably more attention.
Perhaps this uncomfortable market is actually worth watching
Everyone loves property when prices are rising.
Auctions are packed.
Buyers panic.
People waive conditions they probably shouldn't.
A property sells $150,000 over expectations and suddenly three neighbours decide theirs must be worth even more.
Then the cycle changes.
Prices soften.
Auctions become quieter.
Listings sit longer.
Buyers negotiate.
Vendors become more realistic.
And everyone says:
“It's a terrible time to buy.”
Is it?
Or is it simply a more uncomfortable time to buy?
Because there's a difference.
I'm not saying November 2026 is the bottom of the market.
I don't know.
Neither does your real estate agent.
Neither does the economist on television.
And neither does the bloke on TikTok leaning against a Lamborghini explaining how he retired at 27.
Nobody rings a bell at the bottom of a property cycle.
You recognise it afterwards.
But please don't read this as “buy anything”
Absolutely not.
A national housing shortage doesn't turn a bad property into a good investment.
You could still buy:
a poorly constructed apartment,
an oversupplied high-rise,
a terrible location,
a property with major owners corporation liabilities,
a compromised block,
an asset with very little scarcity,
or simply pay far too much.
You can make a terrible purchase in a rising market.
And you can make an exceptional purchase in a falling market.
Asset selection still matters enormously.
The argument isn't:
“Australia needs homes, therefore all property will go up.”
That's far too simplistic.
The much more interesting question is:
Which types of property will remain genuinely scarce if Australia continues struggling to build enough housing?
Established houses.
Land-rich property.
Quality villa units.
Boutique townhouses.
Well-located apartments with characteristics that cannot easily be replicated.
Properties near employment, transport, schools and infrastructure.
That's where the conversation becomes much more sophisticated than simply:
“Will the market go up next year?”
Maybe we're asking the wrong question
Australia spends an incredible amount of energy debating:
Who should be allowed to buy the houses we already have?
Investors.
First-home buyers.
Foreign purchasers.
SMSFs.
Owner-occupiers.
But perhaps the bigger issue is:
Why don't we have enough houses in the first place?
Rearranging ownership of Australia's existing housing stock can absolutely change affordability and access.
But it does not, by itself, substantially increase the number of front doors.
And when your population is growing by almost 400,000 people a year, front doors matter.
So is now actually a good time to buy property?
There is no universal answer.
For someone financially stretched?
Perhaps not.
For somebody with uncertain employment?
Perhaps not.
For somebody who might need to sell again in two years?
You would want to be extremely cautious.
But for a financially secure purchaser with good borrowing capacity and a 10, 15 or 20-year horizon?
I think this market deserves very serious attention.
Not because prices can't fall further.
They can.
Not because every property is a good investment.
It isn't.
And certainly not because property “always goes up”.
It doesn't.
But because underneath today's falling prices sits a structural issue that has not disappeared.
Australia's population is growing.
We need 1.2 million additional homes.
We're not expected to deliver them on schedule.
Construction remains expensive.
Investor borrowing has just suffered its largest quarterly fall on record.
And the cost of borrowing money is significantly higher than it was a year ago.
Put all of that together and today's property market starts looking rather unusual.
Perhaps the question isn't “Will prices fall another 5%?”
Perhaps the better question is:
What will a genuinely scarce piece of Australian residential property be worth in 10 or 20 years if we continue adding people faster than we can comfortably provide housing for them?
Because markets change.
Governments change.
Tax rules change.
Interest rates change.
Sentiment changes.
But one economic principle has survived a very long time:
When something people genuinely need remains scarce, scarcity matters.
Australia wants cheaper homes.
We want cheaper rents.
We want more first-home buyers.
We want fewer investors competing for established property.
And we want 1.2 million additional homes.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with wanting all of those things.
But eventually we have to confront the uncomfortable question:
What if some of the things we're doing to make housing cheaper today also make it harder to provide the housing we're going to need tomorrow?
Now that's a property conversation worth having.
This article contains general property market commentary only and does not constitute financial, legal, taxation or investment advice. Housing markets and individual properties perform differently. Statistics are based on the latest publicly available information as at 12 November 2026.









Comments